Tuesday, September 4, 2012

Class Four: Goals, Issues, and Conclusions

Argument: Goals, Issues, and Conclusions
Class Four: September 6, 2012

Introduction to Goals
Every argument is an undertaking (means) to accomplish a goal (end).  
There are three broad categories of goals:
  • First Person - Goals to affect yourself.  
  • Second Person - Goals to affect your opponent.  
  • Third Person - Goals to affect listeners of the argument.
Any argument that results in you meeting your goal, is an argument you have won.  You will almost always lose an argument if you do not know, or forget, your goal.  Therefore keep your goal in mind when arguing.  This will help you stay on track, shape your argument, and determine whether your goal has been, or can be, reached. 
Since setting a goal in an argument determines nearly every aspect of the argument that follows, it is crucial to understand the proper goals of an argument and keep them constantly in mind.  In certain cases your goal may be readily and apparently achievable - you will know then that you have accomplished what you sought to achieve.  In many cases, a long time may pass before you find out, if at all, that your argument succeeded.  In some cases, certain goals are simply not achievable - ever. 
“Winning” an argument does not necessarily mean that you have compelled, through logic and eloquence, the opposition to concede.   It is an unalterable fact of human existence, that you cannot make an argument that will achieve every possible goal you may select.  In the face of this reality, the first step to any argument, and the most important, is to recognize and select a proper goal or goals that you may actually achieve.
Knowing your goal is so important that the moment you realize your goal cannot be achieved - it is time to stop arguing.
Types of Goals
First Person Goals
First Person Goals are the easiest to acheive.  You may engage in an argument for entertainment, practice, and education.  
The Pleasure of Intellectual Debate.  There is a rare person who actually enjoys the argument and the debate.  It is a form of sport, a logical challenge, and a pleasure that has been enjoyed since antiquity.  Argument can be like virtual chess, honing your ability to listen, dissect, and respond. Older than chess, argument requires you examine your own beliefs, and anticipate your opponent’s next move.
You can also engage in argument to feed your ego, reveling in your assumed mastery of logic.   
Second Person Goals
The person you are arguing against is the “second person.”  Here, you are looking to affect your opponent.  These goals include: persuade, inform, and oppose.  Changing the opposition’s mind to adopt your position on the argument is a common assumed goal.  This is, I suspect, what most people think that their goal should be when entering an argument.  Unfortunately it is the goal that you are least likely to achieve.
Change Behavior.  The distinction between change someone’s mind, and changing his or her behavior is not difficult.  Change someone’s mind, their behavior follows as a result.  Sometimes, however, it is not possible, or time-effective to alter someone’s beliefs, and instead persuade him or her to follow your instructions even if he or she does not believe or adopt the reason why.  Most parents eventually reach this goal when they say, “Because I said so.”
Speaking up to confront an improper action or statement or to defend a person or ideal that has been attacked.  You may be presented with an action, or statement, that requires you to speak up and confront the statement so that (1) your silence is not taken as agreement; or (2) you have a moral duty to confront a statement or action you perceive as wrong.   You perceive that someone, or something, is getting attacked, and you wish to defend that person, or idea.  
Explain your Position or Rationale.  When accused of something, or asked why you took an action, or adopted a position, you may seek merely to state your position so that it is understood - even if you do not hope to persuade.
Third Person Goals
Altering the position of a spectator of the argument.  In this case, you seek to convince the audience, not your opponent, to adopt your position.  Political Debates, are classic examples of this type of goal.  You will never get your political opponent to publicly agree you are the best candidate, however you have a chance with those who witness the debate.  These goals include to inform, persuade, and entertain the listeners.
Selecting your Goal
Select Achievable Goals

Since argument is only a means to an end, you should only engage in arguments if you have an acceptable chance of achieving your goal.  Identifying your goal is therefore the most important decision you can make before you even start the argument.  If your goal is never to lose an argument then you accomplish your goal by avoiding the argument in the first place.  If your goal is to win every argument then you need to pick your battles very wisely.  Often it takes more thought, acumen and wisdom in deciding when to argue and what to let pass.  When arguing with someone, question whether obtaining that person’s agreement should be your goal.

Select Proper Goals

Not all goals, even if achievable, are proper to obtain.  Arguments designed to bring humiliation, or for self-aggrandizement, may not be in your best interest.  

  • Before arguing figure out whether you really have a dog in the fight – if not don’t get involved.  
  • Portraying yourself as an intelligent individual with “the Answer.”  Rare is the individual, who does not desire to be the individual with most intelligence.  You can solve all problems, explain all mysteries, and hopefully, others will appreciate your brilliance.  This sort of vanity bodes poorly for you.
  • Belittle, Mock, Demean, Intimidate.  Some view argument as a means to attack, and assert petty dominance.  If that is your goal, then put this book down.  It isn’t for you.  I would recommend any number of sarcastic books teaching you the art of the put-down.  This book will not help you.

Introduction to Issues
Put simply, the issue is the precise question that will be answered by the end point conclusion.  
Determining the issue is the next important step toward mastering the Gentle Art of Arguments.  If you begin an argument without knowing the issue, you will founder and lose every single time.  The issue will determine not only end-point-conclusion, but also which facts are relevant and, to a large degree, which rule will be used to evaluate the facts.
For example, if the issue is to determine the area of a circle - that immediately requires we use the rule that the area of a circle is πr2 - that is the area of the circle is determined by multiplying Pi by the length of the radius and then squaring the result.  Knowing the rule, we can thus determine the relevant facts needed and necessary to resolve the issue.  These are (1) the value of π; and (2) the length of the radius.  Any other fact that does not reveal either the value of π or the value of the radius is irrelevant.  
That’s how important determining what the issue is before you begin an argument.  It determines not only the rule, but also the facts that may properly be marshaled to support your position.  
Determining the Issue
Given how important the issue is to an argument, how do you determine the issue.  This takes a great deal experience, and will depend upon a number of factors:
  • Your goal may determine the issue.  If your goal is not convince your opponent, but rather a third person, you may select an issue that is important to the third person.  You may also seek to stick an issue you know that you have stronger command of facts and rules.
  • The setting or context of an argument will likely determine the issue.  Arguments in the political process will have different issues than arguments in Supreme Court.  
  • Getting Agreement on the Issue
  • Goals are always easier to reach if all the parties to an argument agree on the issue to be resolved.  Unhappily, that is often not the case.  When possible, always try to obtain agreement as to the issue.  This ensures that the argument does not stray into irrelevant territory.  If you cannot obtain an agreement on the issue, and this is an argument you still wish to enter, then understand both your and your opponent’s issues.  
  • Failure to Agree on the Issue
  • If you feel like you are arguing past each other, or your opponent starts switching to another issue - quickly address the split.  Otherwise your chances of reaching your goal are greatly diminished.  
  • Irreconcilable Issues.  When you perceive that you are arguing two different issues, and you have been unable to get agreement on the issue, then you have two options:  (1) Be prepared to argue why your selected issue is superior to the other perceived issue; and (2) Be prepared to proceed along two separate argument tracks simultaneously; or (3) Obtain agreement to finish one issue first and then proceed to the other issue.
  • Switching Issues.  In lay terms this is called “changing the topic.”  Immediately call your opponent on the attempt to switch the topic.  If it is a relevant, but tangential issue, then seek to obtain agreement to finish one issue before starting a new issue.  It is perfectly acceptable for you point to the effort to switch the issue as a concession that you have a superior argument.
Introduction to Conclusions
There are two types of conclusions in The Gentle Art of Argument: (1) End-Point-Conclusion and (2) Supporting Conclusions.  
End-Point-Conclusions.  These conclusions are the final dispositive answer or allegation that resolves the declared issue.  End-Point-Conclusions are the “point” to all the argument and effort.  End-Point-Conclusions are supported by (1) Determined Facts; (2) Adopted Rules; and (3) Supporting Conclusions.
Supporting Conclusions.  While these conclusions are also supported by (1) Determined Facts and (2) Adopted Rules - these conclusions are not the “point” of the argument.  However often in arguments, and always in complex arguments, supporting conclusions are necessary to reach the End-Point-Conclusion.

Identifying Conclusions

Conclusions are statements that prompt the questions such as why?; how?; so what?; or how do we know that?  Once you distinguish Conclusions from Facts and Rules, you may be surprised how often arguments rely upon unsupported conclusions.  

Types of Conclusions
There are several types of Conclusions.  Here are nine of them:
  1. Cause & Effect Conclusions.  Cause & Effect Conclusions run the gamut from (a) Causal -  If A then B; to (b) Effect - If B came about then A was present; to (c) Prediction- If An occurs then B will happen.
  2. Prediction Conclusions.  Prediction Conclusions are another form of cause & effect - if this occurs thens
  3. Comparison Conclusions - A is (is not) the same as / equal to / analogous to B.
  4. Preference Conclusions - A tastes better than B.
  5. Nature Conclusions - He did that because he is mean.
  6. Aspirational Conclusions - We should treat people better.
  7. Factual Conclusions - The room is thirty square feet.
  8. Rule Conclusions - You cannot spend more than you make.
  9. Abstract Conclusions - are statements that convey a metric, but in fact do not.  For example, it is small.  Small compared to what?

Thursday, August 30, 2012

Class Three: Introduction to Law



Reading for Tuesday's Class • September 4, 2012

WHAT IS LAW?
What defines law?  What distinguishes moral obligation or ethical obligation from a legal obligation?  
When does my duty to keep a clean yard pass from being a personal desire, to a moral or ethical obligation, to a duty that can be enforced by the state?
For purposes of this class, a law is defined as an obligation or prohibition that can be enforced by the power of the state.  
The obligation can take the form of a Prohibition (You cannot travel faster than 25 miles an hour) or in the form of a Duty (You shall file your Income Tax Report).  The power of the state, ultimately, relies upon the legal use of force, giving rise to the maxim - “Behind every law there is a gun.”
•••
KINDS OF LAW
When we discuss a law - any law - it is important that we know what kind of law we discuss.  Often the kind of law at issue will determine how the question is answered, and affect our method of resolving the issue.  Relevant to this class, the character (or kind) of law is determined by two factors: (1) The Character; (2) The Source; and in certain cases an additional description - (3) The Level.
CHARACTER OF LAW
 There are five “characters” of law:
1. Constitutional - the Founding Document of the political regime.  A constitution sets up three broad areas (1) The Structure of Government; (2) The Powers granted to the Government; (3) The Powers denied to the Government.
2. Treaties - Treaties are agreements (often enforceable) entered into between sovereigns.
3. Statutes - In general, when the Legislature passes a bill, the bill becomes a law, and that law is called a Statute.  Laws passed by the Colorado Legislature are called, Colorado Revised Statutes.  Federal laws passed by Congress are also called Statutes, and also United States Code.
4. Regulations - In carrying out its obligation under the law, the Executive is often, if not always, required to establish rules that flesh out, give substance to, and accomplish the intent of the law.  These rules are called Regulations.
5. Case Law - When courts determine how to resolve a particular dispute, or what an ambiguous word in the statute means, that ruling will be relied upon in the future courts.  
SOURCES OF LAW
Law must come from somewhere - some government entity must create it.  For purposes of our class, there are three sources of law  - Federal, State or Local (County or City).    
LEVELS OF (CASE) LAW 
When dealing with case law, it is relevant to know from what level of court established the case law you cite.  For our purposes, from highest to lowest, there are three: (1) Supreme Court; (2) Court of Appeals; and (3) Trial Court.
BRINGING IT TOGETHER
Throughout class I may ask you - what kind of law is it?  Federal Statute?  State Supreme Court Case Law?  State Regulation?  City Statute?  The answer to that question will often determine how we resolve the issue before you.  If we are dealing with case law, I would want to know if the case law you cite is Federal Court of Appeals Decision, or a State Supreme Court Decision, or a Trial Court Decision.
PRECEDENT
“Precedent” is defined as an earlier event or action that is used as a guide in dealing with a future similar situation.  In the legal setting the term means the rule established in a prior case that may - or must - be followed by courts when dealing with a later similar situation.  Another word is called “authority.”  Precedent can either be “binding” or “persuasive.”
Precedent can be binding if the prior decision is from a directly higher court.  In the Federal Court setting, a Federal Court Trial Judge in Colorado must follow a decision established in the Court of Appeals for the 10th Circuit because Colorado is in the 10th Circuit.  Similarly, a decision in by the United Supreme Court is binding on all Courts of Appeals and Federal Court Judges throughout the nation.
However if that same Federal Court Judge is given a decision by the 9th Circuit of the Court of Appeals, the rule established by such a decision is merely “persuasive,” meaning that the Judge is free to adopt, or disregard, the rule established in the decision.  Decisions by other Judges, even in the same Circuit, are merely persuasive.
When a Judge fails to respect binding precedent, it is grounds for reversal upon appeal.  
How the Law Evolves
We need courts and case law in order to permit laws written years ago to be applied to situations today.  While we would like to think that laws can be drafted carefully to cover all possible future scenarios, the reality is different.  It is simply impossible for a legislature to anticipate all the myriad of variations that may occur that touch upon the law.  Further, legislatures often use imprecise words that may have subtle but different meanings, and those competing interpretations must be reconciled by the courts.
When courts are faced with a new situation that the current rule does not readily solve, they must modify the rule, and explain in writing why the modification is necessary.  Then that modification becomes part of the rule that later courts will apply to future situations.  Part of Legal Research is to determine what changes have occurred to the rule in a case you have found that supports (or challenges) your position.

Assignment One


Due Monday, September 3, 2012 by 11:59PM.
(Papers received late will be reduced ten percent of each 15 minute segment they are late)

Review the paper you emailed for passive voice and where appropriate, change the phrasing to active voice.  Please BOLD the sentences you change.  When submitting your assignment back to me please title it:

Baseline V.2. (Your Name).docx

As always be sure to put "ID420" in the subject line.

Thank you!


Wednesday, August 29, 2012

Class Two: Writing - Eliminate Passive Voice


Writing Step One: Eliminate Passive Voice or....Passive Voice was ruthlessly eliminated.
The number one best tip to make your writing direct and fresh is to ruthlessly eliminate phrases written in the passive voice with few exceptions.  Those exceptions should be deliberate and justifiable.  
Passive Voice occurs in a sentence when the emphasis of the sentence is upon the recipient of the action - rather than the actor.  The easiest way to locate and remove passive voice is to search for “to be” verbs such as: are; is; have been; were; and was.  Anytime those word precede another verb - you are looking at passive voice.  Remove those words and you have an active sentence.
EXAMPLE:
Jim was shot by Bob. (Passive Voice) 
CHANGE TO
Bob shot Jim.  (Active Voice)

There are three reasons to use passive:
  1. When it is more important to draw our attention away from the actor and to the person or thing acted upon.  This may because we do not the identity of the actor, or wish not put the focus there.  The phrase “mistakes were made” is now legion in politics.  On January 27, 1987, U.S. President Ronald Reagan used the phrase in the State of the Union Address while discussing contacts with Iran in what came to be known as the arms-for-hostages scandal within the Iran-Contra affair. He said, in part: “And certainly it was not wrong to try to secure freedom for our citizens held in barbaric captivity. But we did not achieve what we wished, and serious mistakes were made in trying to do so. We will get to the bottom of this, and I will take whatever action is called for.”
  2. When the actor in the situation is not important: The meteor shower can be observed after two a.m..
  3. Writing in scientific or technical writing or lab reports, where the process or principle is the main point of the writing.  
  4. In other words, use passive voice rarely and deliberately.
PROOF READING PRACTICE:
Rewrite the following sentences and paragraphs by eliminating passive voice.  Be prepared to go over this in class:
  1. The tall woman in her thirties was immediately visible to him.   She was standing to the side with her older brother Steven.   She was saying goodbye. 
EXAMPLE REWRITE:  He immediately saw a woman in her thirties saying goodbye to her older brother Steven standing next to her.
  • Things outside the Valley were getting worse, not better.  The Federal Government had cancelled most air travel and imposed quarantine measures at the ports.  Merchant Marine vessels were anchored off shore for at least two weeks to ensure they are Influenza Free.
EXAMPLE REWRITE:  Things outside the valley were worse, not better.  The Federal Government cancelled most air travel and imposed quarantine measures at the ports.  Merchant Marine vessels anchored off shore for two weeks to ensure they were influenza free.
  • As they descended, sweaters and coats were stowed away.



  • Monica and Michael got out of the jeep that Sheriff Dove was driving to look inside.  

Tuesday, August 28, 2012

Class One: Introduction to Argument



Introduction to Arguments
An argument is a conclusion derived from applying adopted rules to determined facts relevant to resolve a specific issue in order to accomplish a goal.  
There are a number of components to this definition:
1. Your Goal in making the argument
2. The issue at hand
3.  Your Adopted Rules
4.  Your Determined Facts
5. Your End-Point-Conclusion
Arguments can be mind numbingly layered, because each of the above components is itself a Conclusion that rests upon other determined facts and adopted rules.  
For example: 
I assert that If you drink the contents of this bottle - you will die.  This is my conclusion.
This Bottle contains Bleach.  - This is an determined fact.
Bleach is a poison - This is a determined fact.
Drinking Poison can kill you - This is an adopted rule.

The Determined Fact that “This Bottle contains Bleach” is also a conclusion. How do I know the bottle contains bleach?  What facts do I rely upon to determine that it does, in fact, contain bleach?  The Label? The smell? Someone’s say so?  
The Adopted Rule that “Drinking Poison can kill you” is also a conclusion.  How do we know this?  What testing was done to determine this?  
Finally the determined fact that “Bleach is a Poison” is itself a conclusion.  It relies upon a factual premise that bleach causes the death of people who drink it.
Obviously in the vast majority of arguments you will never distill each and every determined fact and adopted rule down to their core.  Nonetheless it is critical for you to understand that each end-point-conclusion rests upon other supporting conclusions about the facts or the rules.  Successfully challenging arguments requires that you identify those supporting conclusions Challenging arguments is the task of identifying those supporting-conclusions of facts or rules which are vulnerable to attack.

Building Blocks of an Argument

Every argument, decision, dispute, or declaration can be reduced to the following equation:

C = I (F/M X R/M)
In the above equation:
C = End-Point-Conclusion.
I = The Issue the argument should resolve
F = Determined Facts
R = Adopted Rule
M = Methodology used to Determine the Facts or Adopt the Rule
There may be a lot of extra words that add flourish and frill to an argument, but in the end every house, from the Hut to the White House is made up of the same elements - walls, floors, doors, and roof.  The rest is ornament that may add or detract from how well you convey these premises and conclusion to your audience.
Because End-Point-Conclusions are the logical (one hopes) results of two or more premises, you should understand that premises make up the vast bulk of any argument.  Because a conclusion is dependent upon the premise, your best bet for articulating, defending, or attacking any argument is to fanatically focus on the disclosed facts and rules as well as force out the hidden unarticulated facts or rules that must necessarily exist to support the end-point conclusion.
Finally, understand that arguments is an undertaking to accomplishing a goal. You want someone to believe something, do something, consider something, or merely understand something.  Often your goal will determine the structure and tone of your argument.

Monday, August 27, 2012

ID 420 Legal Research & Writing Fall 2012 Class Syllabus


ID 420 Legal Research & Writing (3 Credits)
Fall 2012 Course Syllabus

Successful completion of this class will provide you with working practical experience in legal advocacy writing. The focus of the course will center on THREE major themes:
·       Argument & Rhetoric – I will teach you the major components of an argument and be able to apply that knowledge to creating, deconstructing, defending or attacking an argument.
·       Legal Research & Authority – I will teach you the components, sources, branches, and types of legal authority – what is blandly labeled as “the law.”  I will also teach you how to find the law and how different legal sources interact with each other.
·       Writing – I will teach you several easy steps you can take immediately to improve your writing.  I will teach you proof reading, style, and structure of good writing.
Instructor & Office Hours

Britton Morrell, Esq.
KAPLAN MORRELL
1305 8th Street
Greeley, Colorado 80631

T:      (970) 356-9898
F:      (970) 356-9899
E:      lawprof@me.com

 Office Hours are as follows:
Wednesdays 3:00 PM to 7:00 PM
Thursdays 8:00 AM to 11:00 AM
Mondays and Wednesdays for the hour prior to class
I have practiced law for over 17 years representing workers in employment law matters.  I am licensed to practice law in Colorado District Court, United States Federal Court, and the Office of Administrative Courts.


YOU MUST CALL AND MAKE AN APPOINTMENT FIRST DUE TO MY SCHEDULE.  IF YOU SHOW UP UNANNOUNCED YOU MAY NOT BE SEEN.

You may also email me as needed.

 

Text

There is no commercial textbook for this class.  I will provide you with handouts via email for a nominal charge ($10.00).  All funds raised will be used to purchase pizza or other dinner for class during review sessions throughout the class.  All assignments will received by email. Toward that end IT IS CRITICAL THAT YOU EMAIL ME AT LAWPROF@ME.COM AND PUT “ID420” IN YOUR SUBJECT LINE SO THAT I CAN FIND YOUR WORK I hope I have made this clear enough.


Grading & Attendance

Grading will be done on a modified curve.  The highest grade in the class will establish the top level of A.  The next 10% of students within ten percent of that score will also receive an A.  All students 11% to 20% below that score will receive a B, and so on.

Class Participation                                30%
Final Writing Sample & Exam                 35%     
April Writing Sample & Exam                 20%
March Writing Sample & Exam              10%
February Writing Sample & Exam          5%

Grading (other than Class Participation) will be done anonymously. 

Class Participation will be graded ONLY when your name is pulled and you are required to participate that class.  You are permitted ONE “Pass” per cycle.  If you are called upon and not present, it will count as your first “Pass.”  Inability to participate in a cogent, intelligent and informed manner for whatever reason will be counted as a Zero for the cycle.  Participation that reveals lack of reading will be given partial credit.  You will be called upon at least THREE cycles during semesters.  In addition I will give out various easy little assignments on a random basis that will affect your participation grade.  Finally I will occasionally provide “magic words” that will result in extra points when used in the next exam whenever I see class attendance on the wane.

Statement as to Accommodation

The University of Northern Colorado and I will make every effort to reasonably accommodate disabilities.  If you have any concerns or requests - please contact me or the Department Head.

What to Expect

You should expect to write a two to three page paper and proof read a paper each week

I will endeavor mightily to make the lecture substantively different than what you have read.  STUDENTS WHO DO NOT COME TO CLASS WILL HAVE SERIOUS PROBLEMS OBTAINING A GOOD EXAM SCORE.   If you are called upon you will be expected to have comments and answers that reflect that you have at least TRIED to read the material.  Questions that show you have read, but are having difficulty understanding the legal jargon are acceptable.

Exams will be a mix of essay and multiple choice.  Exams will (naturally) cover material in class and in the readings.

THIS IS NOT A CLASS TO TAKE IF YOU CANNOT MAKE IT REGULARLY TO CLASS.  IN LAW SCHOOL LEGAL RESEARCH & WRITING IS A YEAR LONG CLASS – WE WILL MOVE QUICKLY.